In his nuanced exposition of the teaching authority of the Catholic Church, Cardinal Dulles, Professor at Fordham University and Professor E...

First came this post and its combox. Next came this post and its combox. Then Paul Hoffer wrote up a lengthy reply, found here .  Unfort...

Whitaker comes to the defense of four arguments from Calvin, which Stapleton attempts to refute, the first of which is (in the words of Calv...

Truth Unites... and Divides said... Q: Does the Magisterium pick and choose among all the writings of the Early Church Fathers to come up wi...

Paul Hoffer has been doing yeoman's work in a recent thread about whether Mary sinned in "anxiously" looking for the boy Jesu...

Catholic Nick said : Y ou said: "Irenaeus was clearly wrong when he said that Peter and Paul founded the church at Rome. " Accor...

Over the last week or so, I've been watching the massive thread on "the Doctrine of the Church" over at Greenbaggins. It star...

Paul Hoffer was kind enough to comment at length on my last post , but unfortunately between his original comment that spawned the aforement...

louis said : It's almost as if he thinks those scripture passages are perspicuous or something. He also evidently thinks he understand...

Umm, right, so Pope Benedict XVI, the Vicar of Christ on Earth, has spoken out in "favor" of the Shroud of Turin , basically sayin...

Rhology said... Hi Nick, I'd like to know sthg specific. Given your claim that to your knowledge no one has ever come up with this a...

Continuing with Scott Windsor: No matter how *I* answer, you will try to find fault with it because, as you stated, your mission is to sow d...

Scott Windsor sets himself over a bishop of the RCC: All I can say is that if I were Speaker Pelosi's bishop, I'd probably do things...

Scott Windsor has responded to some of our recent interactions on his blog, in two parts. I'll address this first part here and then g...

Given the recent discussions surrounding the infallibility of the Roman Magisterium, I have 4 questions to help further mutual understanding...

Alexander Greco has graced us with an exposition of the worth of the Magisterium. He apparently can't tell when I am engaging his posit...